|Page tools: Print Page|
This page was updated on 23 Nov 2012 to include the disclaimer below. No other content in this article was affected.
The Royal Commission found that, generally speaking, the disproportionate level of custodial deaths of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people which occurred nationally in the 1980s was a result of their disproportionate levels of incarceration, rather than systematic patterns of foul play, deliberate violence or brutality on the part of police or prison officers. It argued that the causes of the disproportionate involvement of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people in the criminal justice system are to be found in the different levels and patterns of offending of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people compared with those of other backgrounds; in the different patterns of policing and the operation of the courts; and in lifestyle differences, with Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people being disadvantaged in various domains including schooling, employment, health and housing, and experiencing discrimination, dispossession from land and the former policies of the forced removal of children from their families (Royal Commission into Aboriginal Deaths in Custody, 1991).
Owing to the absence of high quality information in many of these areas, the Royal Commission recommended, and all Australian Governments agreed, that the National Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Survey be conducted by the Australian Bureau of Statistics.
The 1994 National Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Survey included a number of questions relating to law and justice, its objective being to fill some of the gaps in information about Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people in the criminal justice system.
The survey design used multi-stage sampling, with stratification on Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Commission Regions. A sample of approximately 15,700 (about 6.6%) of the Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people was interviewed. A sample of prisoners was also included in the survey to ensure that estimates at the State/Northern Territory and national levels reflect the characteristics and attitudes of all Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people (ABS, 1994).
Perceptions of police performance
Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people other than those in prison were asked about their perceptions of police performance in dealing with crime, violence and family violence in their local area. Approximately 37% of the persons aged 13 years and over thought that police performed well in dealing with crime and with violence. A lower proportion (30%) expressed satisfaction at police dealings with family violence (table S3.1).
The main reasons given for dissatisfaction with police in dealing with crime, violence and family violence were that they were too slow to respond, they did not have an understanding of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people or culture, and they did not fully investigate. A relatively low proportion of persons gave lack of police or patrol cars as the reason they were dissatisfied with police.
In 1994, 45% of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people felt that family violence was a common problem in their area, 24% felt that it was not and 31% stated that they did not know. While similar proportions of males and females were unsure, a higher proportion of females (48%) than of males (42%) felt it to be a common problem in the local area.
The highest proportion of people who perceived that family violence was a common problem in their area was among people 25-44 years of age. The teenagers 13-17 years old had the lowest level of perception of family violence (31%). The different perceptions of males and females was particularly marked in the 18-24 years age group: while 50% of 18-24 year old females felt family violence to be a common problem in the area, only 39% of males felt this way. Similar proportions of males and females in the older (25-44 and 45+ years) age groups considered that it was a common problem (see graph S3.2).
Although substantial proportions of respondents from both the urban and rural areas saw family violence as a common problem locally, this perception was more widely held in the non-capital city urban areas (51% of respondents) and rural areas (49%) than in the capital cities (32%). Women in the non-capital urban areas were most likely to perceive family violence to be a problem (53%), whereas this was least likely among capital city males (28%).
Experience of criminal victimisation
Higher proportions of respondents in capital cities experienced this form of victimisation (17%) than people in other urban areas (12%) or rural areas (10%). Overall, a slightly higher proportion of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander males (14%) than females (12%) were attacked or verbally threatened. Males living in the capital cities experienced the highest incidence (19%), almost one in five.
Of the Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people aged 13 years and above who were attacked or verbally threatened in the year prior to interview, 66% were attacked or threatened more than once. This compared with 44% of assault victims from the 1993 National Crime and Safety Survey. Overall the frequencies were broadly similar for males and females; 17% of females had been victims 10 or more times, compared with 14% of males (graph S3.3).
About one-third (37%) of the last incidents of attack or verbal threat were reported to the police; 49% of the female victims, compared with 26% of the male victims, reported the last incident to the police.
Experiences with the law
A higher proportion of males were arrested more than once in the previous five years (19%) than were arrested just once (12%). Both the likelihood of arrest and the frequency of arrest were particularly high among males in the age groups 18-24 years and 25-44 years (47% and 38% respectively) compared with people in the other age groups.
As with males, females aged 18-24 years had a relatively high level of arrests, with 8.4% arrested once over the five years and 7.7% more than once.
The respondents who had been arrested were asked to identify the reason for their last arrest. Some gave more than one reason. The reason most frequently reported was 'disorderly conduct/drinking in public' at 32%, followed by 'drink driving' offences at 23% (see graph S3.5).
For both male and female Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people, disorderly conduct/drinking in public was the most common reason for the most recent arrest, (31% and 38%, respectively). The second most common reason for males was drink driving (26%); for females it was assault (19%).
National Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Survey, An Evaluation of the Survey, 1994 (4184.0).
National Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Survey, Detailed findings, 1994 (4190.0).
Occasional Paper, Law and Justice Issues, Indigenous Australians, 1994 (4189.0).
Royal Commission into Aboriginal Deaths in Custody 1991, National Report (Chairperson: E. Johnston), AGPS, Canberra.
These documents will be presented in a new window.