Appendix A Observations from the 2016 Report – what was implemented and how

Report on the quality of 2021 Census data: Statistical Independent Assurance Panel to the Australian Statistician

An independent view of the quality of statistical outputs from the 2021 Census of Population and Housing

Released
28/06/2022

Overview

Decorative banner

In reviewing the 2016 Census data, the 2016 Census Independent Assurance Panel identified some opportunities for the ABS to consider in order to enhance future Censuses, as follows:

  1. The change in collection approach led to challenges in the determination of whether dwellings were occupied on Census night, which impacts on the number of people that are imputed and the overall Census response rate. The ABS should consider new approaches to improve the accuracy of occupancy determination in future Censuses. This could involve administrative data sources or a special survey of non-responding dwellings as is done in Canada.
  2. The results of the Post Enumeration Survey indicated that the Census person imputation can be improved. The ABS should consider new approaches to person imputation for future Censuses, including post Census adjustments based on the Post Enumeration Survey down to small area geographies.
  3. The use of the Address Register likely led to the increase in the number of dwellings that have no information for their structure type, as well as a decrease in the proportion of dwellings classified as flats and apartments attached to houses. While the proportion of the overall dwelling stock that these issues affect is small, improved field procedures or access to administrative files could lessen the impact of this in future Censuses.
  4. The 2016 Census results for Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples are comparable to those from the 2011 Census, although the coverage of these populations remains lower than that of the general population. Given the importance of producing representative information about Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples, the ABS should consider ways of improving the coverage of these populations ahead of future Censuses, in consultation with Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander communities.
  5. Even though their contribution to the overall population is small, the lower response rate for non-private dwellings has had some effect on quality. Methods for improving the response rate and/or the accuracy of identifying the number of non-responding persons in non-private dwellings for whom imputation is necessary should be investigated.
  6. Given the decline in the reporting of date of birth and the reduced proportion of people choosing to have their form retained by the National Archives, the ABS should consider how it can best respond to privacy concerns for future Censuses and provide appropriate assurances to the public. In particular, the ABS should consider sourcing an external Privacy Impact Assessment for future Censuses.
  7. The establishment of an Independent Assurance Panel to review the quality of Census data provides greater transparency and accountability. The establishment of such a Panel should be repeated for future Censuses to provide additional assurance on the quality of the valuable national resource that is the Australian Census. If this measure is pursued for future Censuses, the ABS should have regard to the timeframe for completion of this work, noting the limitations associated with delivering a report coincident with the release of the Census data.

The extent to which these opportunities were addressed in the design of the 2021 Census and enacted during operations is summarised below.

A.1 New approaches to improve the accuracy of occupancy determination

A.2 New approaches to person imputation, including post-Census adjustments based on the Post Enumeration Survey down to small area geographies

A.3 New approaches to field procedures and the possible use of administrative files to improve the Address Register information on dwelling structure

A.4 Methods to improve the enumeration of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples, explored in consultation with Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander communities

A.5 Methods to improve the response rate and/or the accuracy of identifying the number of non-responding persons in non-private dwellings for whom imputation is necessary

A.6 How best to respond to privacy concerns and provide assurances to the public, in particular considering the sourcing of an external Privacy Impact Assessment

A.7 Continuing the practice of an Independent Assurance Panel

Back to top of the page