6278.0 - Education and Training Experience, Australia, 2005  
ARCHIVED ISSUE Released at 11:30 AM (CANBERRA TIME) 29/05/2006   
   Page tools: Print Print Page Print all pages in this productPrint All



TECHNICAL NOTE RELIABILITY OF ESTIMATES


RELIABILITY OF ESTIMATES

1 Since the estimates in this publication are based on information obtained from occupants of a sample of dwellings, they are subject to sampling variability. That is, they may differ from those estimates that would have been produced if all dwellings had been included in the survey. One measure of the likely difference is given by the standard error (SE), which indicates the extent to which an estimate might have varied by chance because only a sample of dwellings was included. There are about two chances in three (67%) that a sample estimate will differ by less than one SE from the number that would have been obtained if all dwellings had been included, and about 19 chances in 20 (95%) that the difference will be less than two SEs. Another measure of the likely difference is the relative standard error (RSE), which is obtained by expressing the SE as a percentage of the estimate.


2 Due to space limitations, it is impractical to print the SE of each estimate in the publication. Instead, tables of SEs and RSEs for estimates of numbers of persons and estimates of numbers of training courses and qualifications appear at the end of these Technical Notes. Each SE table is derived from a mathematical model, referred to as the "SE model", which is created using the data collected in this survey. It should be noted that the SE model only gives an approximate value for the SE for any particular estimate, since there is some minor variation among SEs for different estimates of the same size. SEs and RSEs for estimates of earnings, income and mean, median and total training hours have not been included in this publication, but are available on request.


Calculation of standard errors

3 An example of the calculation and use of SEs in relation to estimates of numbers of persons is as follows. Table 15 shows that the estimated number of persons aged 25 to 34 who have completed one non-school qualification is 1,160,600. Since this estimate is between 1,000,000 and 2,000,000 in the SE table for person estimates, the SE will be between 15,600 and 20,600, and can be approximated by interpolation as 16,400 using the following general formula:


Equation: SE of estimate


4 Therefore, there are about two chances in three that the value that would have been produced if all dwellings had been included in the survey will fall within 16,400 persons of the survey estimate, i.e. in the range 1,144,200 to 1,177,000, and about 19 chances in 20 that the value will fall within 32,800 persons of the survey estimate, i.e. in the range 1,127,800 to 1,193,400. This example is illustrated in the diagram below.

Diagram: Calculation of standard errors


5 In general, the size of the SE increases as the size of the estimate increases. Conversely, the RSE decreases as the size of the estimate increases. Very small estimates are thus subject to such high RSEs that their value for most practical purposes is unreliable. In the tables in this publication, only estimates with RSEs of 25% or less are considered reliable for most purposes. Estimates with RSEs greater than 25% but less than or equal to 50% are preceded by an asterisk (e.g. *3.4) to indicate they are subject to high SEs and should be used with caution. Estimates with RSEs of greater than 50%, preceded by a double asterisk (e.g. **0.3), are considered too unreliable for general use and should only be used to aggregate with other estimates to provide derived estimates with RSEs of 25% or less.


6 The SE can be calculated from the RSE and the estimate using the following formula:


Equation: SE formula



PROPORTIONS AND PERCENTAGES

7 Proportions and percentages formed from the ratio of two estimates are also subject to sampling errors. The size of the error depends on the accuracy of both the numerator and the denominator. A formula to approximate the RSE of a proportion is given below. This formula is only valid when x is a subset of y:


Equation: RSE proportion


8 Consider the example above of the number of people who have completed one non-school qualification aged 25 to 34 (1,160,600). Of these, 596,100 or 51.4% were estimated to be male. The SE of 1,160,600 is approximately 16,400 so the RSE is 1.4%. The RSE for 596,100 is 2.1%. Applying the formula above, the RSE of the proportion is 1.5%, giving a SE for the proportion (51.4%) of 0.8 percentage points. Therefore there are about two chances in three that the proportion of persons aged 25 to 34 who have completed one non-school qualification who were male is between 50.6% and 52.2%, and 19 chances in 20 that the proportion is within the range 49.8% and 53.0%.


Differences

9 Published estimates may also be used to calculate the difference between two survey estimates (of numbers or percentages). Such an estimate is subject to sampling error. The sampling error of the difference between two estimates depends on their SEs and the relationship (correlation) between them. An approximate SE of the difference between two estimates (x-y) may be calculated by the following formula:


Equation: SE of differences


10 While this formula will only be exact for differences between separate and uncorrelated characteristics or sub-populations, it is expected to provide a good approximation for all differences likely to be of interest in this publication. Actual RSEs are available on request.


Standard Errors

STANDARD ERRORS OF PERSON ESTIMATES

AUST.
NSW
Vic.
Qld
SA
WA
Tas.
NT
ACT
SE
RSE
Size of estimate (persons)
no.
no.
no.
no.
no.
no.
no.
no.
no.
%

100
150
140
130
110
120
90
110
70
150
150.0
200
230
220
210
170
190
150
170
130
220
110.0
300
300
280
270
220
240
200
210
170
280
93.3
500
420
390
370
300
320
270
280
240
380
76.0
700
510
480
450
360
390
320
340
300
460
65.7
1,000
630
590
550
440
470
390
410
370
560
56.0
1,500
800
750
690
550
590
480
490
450
700
46.7
2,000
940
880
810
630
680
550
560
520
810
40.5
2,500
1 050
1 000
900
700
750
600
600
600
900
36.0
3,000
1 200
1 100
1 000
800
850
650
650
600
1 000
33.3
3,500
1 300
1 200
1 100
850
900
700
700
650
1 100
31.4
4,000
1 350
1 250
1 150
900
950
750
750
700
1 200
30.0
5,000
1 550
1 400
1 300
1 000
1 100
800
800
750
1 300
26.0
7,000
1 850
1 700
1 550
1 150
1 250
900
900
850
1 600
22.9
10,000
2 150
2 000
1 800
1 350
1 500
1 000
1 050
950
1 900
19.0
15,000
2 650
2 450
2 200
1 600
1 800
1 150
1 150
1 000
2 300
15.3
20,000
3 000
2 750
2 500
1 800
2 000
1 250
1 250
1 100
2 650
13.3
30,000
3 600
3 300
2 950
2 150
2 400
1 350
1 400
1 150
3 250
10.8
40,000
4 050
3 750
3 350
2 400
2 700
1 450
1 500
1 200
3 750
9.4
50,000
4 450
4 100
3 650
2 600
2 950
1 500
1 600
1 200
4 150
8.3
100,000
5 850
5 350
4 750
3 300
3 850
1 650
1 800
1 200
5 750
5.8
150,000
6 800
6 200
5 500
3 800
4 500
1 700
1 900
1 200
6 900
4.6
200,000
7 550
6 850
6 100
4 150
4 950
1 750
2 000
1 150
7 850
3.9
300,000
8 650
7 850
7 000
4 650
5 700
1 750
. .
1 050
9 400
3.1
500,000
10 150
9 250
8 200
5 350
6 750
1 750
. .
. .
11 700
2.3
1,000,000
12 400
11 250
10 000
6 400
8 350
. .
. .
. .
15 600
1.6
2,000,000
14 800
13 400
12 000
7 400
10 100
. .
. .
. .
20 600
1.0
5,000,000
18 100
16 350
14 750
. .
. .
. .
. .
. .
29 350
0.6
10,000,000
20 600
. .
. .
. .
. .
. .
. .
. .
37 900
0.4
15,000,000
. .
. .
. .
. .
. .
. .
. .
. .
43 850
0.3
20,000,000
. .
. .
. .
. .
. .
. .
. .
. .
48 500
0.2

. . not applicable

ESTIMATES WITH RELATIVE STANDARD ERRORS OF 25% AND 50%

NSW
Vic.
Qld.
SA
WA
Tas.
NT
ACT
Aust.
Size of estimate (persons)
no.
no.
no.
no.
no.
no.
no.
no.
no.

Estimates with RSEs of 25%
7 600
6 500
5 400
3 200
3 700
2 400
2 400
2 200
5 600
Estimates with RSEs of 50%
1 700
1 500
1 200
800
900
600
700
500
1 300

STANDARD ERRORS OF WORK-RELATED TRAINING COURSES & QUALIFICATION ESTIMATES

AUST.
NSW
Vic.
Qld
SA
WA
Tas.
NT
ACT
SE
RSE
Size of estimate (training & qualifications)
no.
no.
no.
no.
no.
no.
no.
no.
no.
%

100
210
230
180
160
210
140
140
120
270
270.0
200
330
350
280
250
310
210
230
180
390
195.0
300
420
440
360
310
390
260
300
240
480
160.0
500
570
580
500
430
510
340
410
330
620
124.0
700
700
700
610
520
610
410
510
410
730
104.3
1,000
860
850
750
640
740
500
620
500
880
88.0
1,500
1 100
1 070
960
800
910
620
780
640
1 080
72.0
2,000
1 300
1 250
1 130
940
1 060
730
920
750
1 250
62.5
2,500
1 450
1 400
1 300
1 050
1 200
800
1 050
850
1 400
56.0
3,000
1 650
1 550
1 450
1 200
1 300
900
1 150
950
1 550
51.7
3,500
1 800
1 700
1 550
1 300
1 400
1 000
1 200
1 000
1 650
47.1
4,000
1 950
1 800
1 700
1 400
1 500
1 050
1 300
1 100
1 800
45.0
5,000
2 200
2 050
1 900
1 550
1 700
1 200
1 450
1 250
2 000
40.0
7,000
2 650
2 450
2 300
1 850
2 050
1 450
1 700
1 450
2 350
33.6
10,000
3 200
2 950
2 800
2 250
2 450
1 750
2 000
1 750
2 850
28.5
15,000
4 000
3 700
3 450
2 750
3 000
2 150
2 350
2 150
3 500
23.3
20,000
4 700
4 300
4 000
3 200
3 450
2 500
2 650
2 450
4 050
20.3
30,000
5 850
5 300
4 950
3 950
4 200
3 100
3 050
2 950
5 000
16.7
40,000
6 800
6 150
5 750
4 550
4 850
3 600
3 400
3 400
5 750
14.4
50,000
7 650
6 900
6 400
5 050
5 400
4 050
3 650
3 700
6 450
12.9
100,000
11 000
9 850
9 050
7 050
7 550
5 850
4 500
4 950
9 200
9.2
150,000
13 550
12 050
11 000
8 500
9 150
7 250
5 000
5 800
11 350
7.6
200,000
15 650
13 950
12 550
9 650
10 500
8 400
5 400
6 500
13 150
6.6
300,000
19 200
17 050
15 150
11 600
12 700
10 400
. .
7 500
16 200
5.4
500,000
24 700
22 000
19 100
14 500
16 100
13 550
. .
. .
21 000
4.2
1,000,000
34 550
30 850
25 850
19 450
22 150
. .
. .
. .
30 000
3.0
2,000,000
48 000
43 050
34 600
25 800
30 250
. .
. .
. .
42 800
2.1
5,000,000
73 200
66 450
50 000
. .
. .
. .
. .
. .
68 450
1.4
10,000,000
. .
. .
. .
. .
. .
. .
. .
. .
97 750
1.0
15,000,000
. .
. .
. .
. .
. .
. .
. .
. .
120 350
0.8

. . not applicable

ESTIMATES WITH RELATIVE STANDARD ERRORS OF 25% AND 50%

NSW
Vic.
Qld
SA
WA
Tas.
NT
ACT
Aust.
Size of estimate (training & qualifications)
no.
no.
no.
no.
no.
no.
no.
no.
no.

Estimates with RSEs of 25%
17 500
14 500
12 600
8 000
9 400
4 500
6 600
4 900
13 000
Estimates with RSEs of 50%
3 700
3 300
2 700
1 800
2 300
1 000
1 700
1 000
3 200