CaSQ 9B - Birth Month Paradox Theoretical Probability
You can download this activity as a rich text file (RTF) using the link at the bottom of the page.
How to: Get a Random Sample from CensusAtSchool
Go to the CensusAtSchool Random Sampler to download a sample.
Reference year: (select year) Sample size:35 students
Select questions:Birth month
Location: Select location Year level:(select a range of year levels)
To protect privacy there is a rule built into the sampler that the requested sample size cannot exceed 10% of the respondents for the parameters entered.
Task:
If you completed worksheet 9A you should have found that in any 5 people, chosen at random, the probability that at least 2 of the 5 will have the same birth month is more than 50%.
This result was reached using a long run experiment where results were compiled after collecting data over many trials.
Experimental probability is mainly used when it is not possible to work out the theoretical probability using the mathematical formula below:
Pr(event) = number of favourable outcomes
number of possible outcomes
The result of the Birth Month paradox can be checked using theoretical probability. However, it can be explained more easily by finding the probability that no 2 birth months will be the same.
Complementary events in probability are events that cannot occur together (e.g. when tossing a coin, obtaining a head is complementary to tossing a tail). The probabilities of complementary events add to 1 i.e. Pr(Event) + Pr(Complement of the Event) = 1
so
Pr (Event) = 1 – Pr (its Complementary Event)
So we can say for 5 people chosen at random:
Pr (at least 2 birth months will be the same) = 1 – Pr (none are the same)
Pr (Person 1 has a birth month) = any month can be chosen
Pr (Person 2 is different to Person 1) = any of the remaining 11 months is ok
Pr (Person 3 is different to Persons 1 & 2) = can choose any of the 10 months left
The birth month paradox is an example of a compound event. This means that there are a number of steps in the event. Another example of a compound event is tossing a coin 3 times.
1. What is the Pr (H, H, H) if we toss a coin 3 times?
This can be shown in a tree diagram.
We can apply this multiplication rule to the birth month paradox.
The Pr (3 people each has a different birth month) =
2. Continue this pattern to find Pr (5 people have different birth months).
3. Use your understanding of complementary events to find, for 5 people chosen at random, Pr (not all birth months will be different). Is this the same as your answer for 9A?
Extension:
Similarly in the birthday paradox:
For every 23 people randomly selected there is a 50% chance that at least 2 will share the same birthday, If there are 30 then there is a 70% probability and if there are 50 the probability rises to 97%.
Unless otherwise noted, content on this website is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 2.5 Australia Licence together with any terms, conditions and exclusions as set out in the website Copyright notice. For permission to do anything beyond the scope of this licence and copyright terms contact us.